Agenda item

8.1

RESOLVED: That (a) the applications now submitted for permission to develop land under the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 and the Regulations made thereunder and for consent under the Town and Country Planning (Control of Advertisements) Regulations 1989, be decided, granted or refused as stated in the report to this Committee for this date in respect of Sheffield Children's NHS Foundation Trust, The Children’s Hospital, Western Bank, 8 to 12 Northumberland Road, 5 to 9 Clarkson Street (Case No. 12/03394/CAC) and other applications considered be amended as in the minutes of this meeting, and the requisite notices issued; the granting of any permission or consent shall not constitute approval, permission or consent by this Committee or the Council for any other purpose;

(b) having noted that the officer’s recommendation, to grant planning permission, would be subject to the completion of a Legal Agreement, as detailed in a supplementary report circulated at the meeting, planning permission for the demolition of offices and erection of 6 dwelling houses with integral garages at the site of Phoenix House, 67 to 73 Common Side (Case No. 12/04037/FUL) be granted, conditionally, subject to the completion of a Legal Agreement;

(c) having noted that authority to undertake enforcement action was sought in connection with the recommendation to refuse planning permission, as detailed in a supplementary report circulated at the meeting, planning permission be refused for the replacement of wooden windows with uPVC at 24 Ashgate Road (Case No. 12/04013/FUL), with authority given for the Director of Development Services or Head of Planning to take all appropriate action including, if necessary, the institution of legal proceedings to secure the removal of the uVPC mock sash windows at 24 Ashgate Road with more appropriate timber sliding sash frames;

(d) in connection with the decision to refuse planning permission for the retention of a combined automated teller machine (ATM) and payphone kiosk at the former telephone box outside 315 to 319 Ecclesall Road (Case No. 12/03838/FUL), authority be given for the Director of Development Services or Head of Planning to take all appropriate action including, if necessary, the institution of legal proceedings to secure the removal of the combined automated teller machine and payphone kiosk outside 315 to 319 Ecclesall Road;

(e) notwithstanding the officer’s recommendation, an application for planning permission for the demolition of an existing disused electrical substation and the erection of 2 terraced dwellinghouses with associated landscaping and car parking provision at the former electricity substation adjacent to 47 Roach Road (Case No. 12/03571/FUL) be refused as the Committee considered that the development was out of character with the surrounding area, which included the use of inappropriate materials, that it would have an overbearing impact, which included the loss of light to neighbouring residents and had insufficient parking provision and as such was contrary to Policies H14 of the Unitary Development Plan, CS31 of the Sheffield Development Framework and in respect of Supplementary Planning Guidance relating to separation distances and the overbearing nature of the development;

(f) having noted that planning reference “Case No. 04/01622/FUL” should be replaced by planning reference “Case No. 04/01622/OUT” under Directive 1, as detailed in a supplementary report circulated at the meeting, an application for planning permission for the erection of a 7.5m high acoustic fence and associated landscaping on land to the south of 91 to 102 Doveholes Drive (Case No.12/03415/FUL) be granted conditionally;

(g) (i) an application to approve details in relation to Condition 13 – sound insulation measures relating to planning permission Case No. 04/01622/OUT at land to the south of 91 to 102 Doveholes Drive (Case No. 12/03452/COND) (i) be deferred, to allow validation of the sound attenuation properties of the proposed acoustic fence, approved at this meeting under planning permission Case No. 12/03415/FUL to be undertaken after construction, to assess that noise levels comply with the aforementioned Condition 13 and (ii) the future discharge of the Condition 13 under planning permission Case No. 04/01622/OUT be reported to a future meeting of this Committee for approval; and

(h) having noted the updated list of plans, as detailed in a supplementary report circulated at the meeting, an application for planning permission for the construction of a new main entrance, outpatients and ward building in the south-east of the hospital site, including new service yard and delivery zone, alterations to 8/10 Northumberland Road, closure of part of Durham Road/part of Durham Lane, alterations/extension of the existing main entrance building along Clarkson Road and provision of a new frontage, demolition of 9 Clarkson Street, and demolition of an extension at 5 to 7 Clarkson Street and at 12 Northumberland Road at Sheffield Children's NHS Foundation Trust, The Children’s Hospital, Western Bank, 8 to 12 Northumberland Road, 5 to 9 Clarkson Street, (Case No. 12/03393/FUL) be granted, conditionally.